How does a team defeat FC Barcelona 4–0 and then lose 3–0 to Rayo Vallecano days later? That is the big question surrounding Atlético Madrid.
Softfootball observed that Atlético’s performance against Rayo was far below the intensity and discipline shown in their dominant Copa del Rey first-leg victory over Barcelona.
Tactical Rotation or Complacency?
Manager Diego Simeone surprisingly benched new signing Ademola Lookman, fueling speculation that he may be preserving key players for the decisive second leg against Barça.
Atlético currently sit 4th in La Liga, while Rayo are 16th, making the defeat even more surprising on paper.
Rayo’s Intensity
Rayo Vallecano approached the match with fearless attacking intent and relentless pressing. Their energy disrupted Atlético’s rhythm from start to finish, exposing defensive gaps rarely seen in Simeone’s structured side.
In contrast, Atlético lacked sharpness, aggression, and cohesion, a complete opposite of the clinical performance that dismantled Barcelona.
What This Means for Barça
This inconsistency offers hope to Barcelona ahead of the Copa del Rey return leg. If Atlético replicate their below-par league display, Barça could believe in a comeback.
However, it is also possible Simeone is prioritizing silverware. With La Liga looking increasingly difficult and other titles uncertain, the Copa del Rey may represent Atlético’s clearest path to a trophy this season.
Final Analysis
The contrast between Atlético’s 4–0 dominance and their 3–0 collapse highlights a team balancing ambition with fatigue and rotation.
The real question now: which Atlético will show up in the second leg, the ruthless giant-slayer or the vulnerable side exposed by Rayo?
