Softfootball understands that Crystal Palace manager Oliver Glasner recently confirmed that Jean-Philippe Mateta would not require surgery following a failed medical ending his $35 million move to AC Milan.
The decision has sparked a wave of reactions from fans on X, with supporters and critics weighing in on the risk and implications for the striker’s future.
Some fans expressed sympathy for Mateta, highlighting the timing of the injury in relation to his career ambitions. Jim (@1206Devisjim) commented on the unfortunate timing.
He wrote:
The injury came in when he was about to upgrade in his football career This life.
Others, however, suggested that Palace should let Mateta undergo surgery first to preserve his market value. KenzyGraphicsWorld (@KGorld) stressed this approach.
He said:
Let him go for surgery and then sell him for a good price. This is the best time to to that.
Fan accounts also chimed in, emphasising the long-term health risks of skipping surgery. Estevão Fan (@estevaowilliam_) shared a cautious perspective.
He stated:
It is better for him to under surgery than to be out and later go back to that surgery.
Some fans questioned the medical advice from both sides, pointing out the potential consequences if Mateta were to aggravate his knee again. Oluwaotobi (@oluwatobitola) highlighted the clash between AC Milan’s medical recommendation and Palace’s assessment.
He warned:
AC Milan doctors said he needed surgery. Palace specialists say he’ll be back in weeks. Someone is wrong, and if Mateta breaks down again, it’s a disaster for Oliver Glasner. To ignore the medical advice of a Champions League giant is a massive risk. Palace are playing with fire.
Finally, some users criticised Palace’s handling of Mateta’s appearances in matches while he was carrying the injury, suggesting the club may have prioritised his transfer value over his well-being. Titan (@BleuTitan) questioned the ethics and global implications.
He concluded:
Why Crystal Palace kept playing him every week, knowing he had a knee issue, to boost his sale value should be studied. So this is a worldwide thing?
The ongoing debate highlights the fine line clubs walk between managing player fitness and navigating lucrative transfer opportunities. Fans continue to monitor Mateta’s recovery closely, weighing the risk to both the player and Crystal Palace’s season.
